Making Comments on Student Writing Meaningful

One reason I love middle school kids

And another reason I love middle school kids

As any English teacher knows, we spend countless hours grading and commenting on student work. What I realized after a few years of teaching was that many students did not read my comments at all; they just looked at their grade. Some didn't even look at the rubric! However, many students valued my feedback and relished every comment. I felt as though I was wasting my time on more than half of the essays. As evident from the next essay the students wrote, the majority of the students did not heed the advice I gave in the previous essay. I came up with a solution! Using Google Forms, I created a detailed survey for my students to fill out about the comments they received on their writing. I will include pictures of various questions and answers. Better yet, I told them that all responses would be read and a graded for the thoughtfulness. I had a sub that day, so I created a link to the form in my daily blog post for my class! SO easy! Students were forced to go back to the two most recent writing assignments and read all of my comments and look at the rubric. They had no choice but to reflect on their strengths and weaknesses. I told them that even if they earned an A, I still made suggestions!
The work I received on this assignment was incredibly thoughtful and insightful. I enjoyed reading their responses and look forward to reading the next writing assignment.
What I like about this assignment is that it encourages learning and improving! It reinforces the idea that there is always room for growth!

Make sure to ask their names or responses are anonymous!

I included this in my survey. :)

Love the checkbox feature!

Comments

TQE: Get students Engaged and Digging Deep

I've mentioned before how Twitter has helped me grow as an educator. Edutwitter is a valuable resource for book recommendations, new teaching methods, lessons, and articles. One of my favorite educators to follow is Marissa Thompson, a high school teacher at Carlsbad High. This summer I read about her TQE(thoughts, questions, epiphanies) method for discussing literature. I'd always longed for having discussions like the ones I had in my college literature courses, but when I try fishbowl or Socratic seminar with my students, the discussions felt forced, flat, and awkward. That changed today when I tried TQE for the first time. Sharing homework in small groups Students writing their TQEs on the board When I listened to Marissa's podcast on Cult of Pedagogy ( check it out here ), I was intimidated. After all, her students are in high school and have a rock star teacher. I think I read the transcript twenty times before finally trying it. Here's h

Writing an Essay...with a Partner

I love technology for collaboration! Teaching writing to middle school students is not easy. All students come with different skills and knowledge. With 35 students in a class, it's impossible to sit down one on one and assist students with the writing process. Teaching students to write a literary analysis is particularly challenging because most seventh-graders have little, to no experience. Students need to learn to develop a thesis statement, find evidence from the text to support it, provide the context of the selected quotations , and write insightful commentary on the evidence they selected. Remember, these kiddos are twelve! Graphic organizers are particularly helpful to these young writers. The biggest challenge is providing feedback to students as they are writing, rather than after they turn their work in for a grade. Students need to be able to use the feedback they receive and see the difference it makes in the final product. I was adamant that I was not go

The Outsiders

Anyone else remember reading The Outsiders in middle school? I remember reading it in 7th grade in 1981. Oh how I loved that book! Then came the movie! Rob Lowe, Tom Cruise, Leif Garret, Matt Dillon, and Patrick Swayze were some of the actors in this Francis Ford Coppola film. I have to admit that it was a little depressing this year when I mentioned that Tom Cruise was in the movie, and only one student said, "I think I have heard of him." Yet, here it is 2014 and my students are enjoying this book as much as I did. On the surface the book is about two rival "gangs," the Socs and the Greasers. However, the book is about so much more. It is about stereotypes and prejudging people. It's about true friendship, family, and loyalty. It's about courage and growing up. That makes it the perfect book for middle schoolers. I started off the unit with a web quest about the 1960s to get the students acquainted with the setting of the novel. They

Learning, Laughter, and Love in Middle School English

Search This Blog