Skip to main content

I Agree: Ditch that Homework


I have been on both ends of the homework equation, teacher and parent. As a teacher, I have assigned it countless times, but it never felt right. Most of the time I felt guilty for assigning it but felt I had to.  I mean, kids spend six hours a day in school. Shouldn't we be able to get our job done in that amount of time?  Shouldn't kids get to go home and spend time with their families, play sports, go to youth group,  play outside, surf, and relax? As a teacher, I've been irritated and frustrated when students did not complete it. I've heard some of the following:


  • I lost it
  • I was sick last night
  • I fell asleep
  • I forgot how to do it
  • I had soccer practice until 9
  • My grandma is in the hospital
  • I had too much math homework
  • My maid threw it away
  • I forgot it
  • Our internet was down
  • My dog ate it (the student handed me paper with tooth marks)
Unfortunately, sometimes my lesson for that day was dependent on students completing their homework. If they didn't have it, they couldn't participate.  Now, who do you think is least likely to complete homework?  Yep! Those with busy parents (nobody to hover over them or assist them) and those who have never "done school" very well.  So what does assigning homework do? It allows those students grades to suffer. The students who do their homework are the students who will do well regardless.

  Many years ago I read a book by Alfie Kohn called The Homework Myth, and it supported everything I had always felt about homework.   I also read The Case Against Homework by Sara Bennett and Nancy Kalish. Again, more validation! My current read is Ditch that Homework by Alice Keeler.  Numerous articles have been published giving credence to the claim that assigning homework does not propel students to academic success.  There is no correlation between homework and student performance.  There is very little evidence to support assigning homework in middle school either!  I would argue that homework is detrimental in all grades because of the negative effect it has on how students feel about school.  
Proponents of homework argue that it prepares students for college, teaches them responsibility, and allows them to practice what they learned in class. My son just finished his freshman year at San Diego State and managed to do very well academically. When I asked him how many hours a week he spent doing homework, he said that it was ten hours at the most.  That's less than some elementary school students! After I had my first baby, I was surviving on about four hours of sleep. Should I have started depriving myself of sleep in preparation for motherhood?  Heck no! In regards to teaching students responsibility, that is a ridiculous reason. I can teach my children responsibility just fine all by myself!  They can do their laundry, vacuum, pick up dog poop, and participate in a variety of activities (sports, church, jobs) that require responsibility.  Oh, but they need PRACTICE!  Okay, but why can't that be done in class?  That way the teacher is there to assist them with any questions!  Catlin Tucker, the author of Blended Learning, encourages teachers to try using stations in their classrooms. This allows the teacher to provide feedback to a small group of students and answer questions they may have.    

As a parent, I have always despised and resented my own children having homework, especially in elementary and middle school.  Many times the assignments involved me having to spend money at Michaels, scrounge up a shoe box, or sign a reading log (don't get me started on reading logs). Other times, one of my kids would be in tears at 9:00 at night because he was tired but still had ten more math problems left to do.   Here's another reason I don't like homework: it can lead to grade inflation.  Last year my son took chemistry. He completed all of his homework but earned Ds or Fs on almost all of his tests. He still managed to pass the class!  Does that seem right?  I think not!
Unfortunately, some students and parents equate homework with rigor.  For example, last year I told one of my students that he should take Honors English next year.  His response was, "I don't know. I don't want a lot of homework."  That is what some people think honors should be--more homework.  No, it should be different work!  In fact, if teachers were willing to personalize learning, we could eliminate honors and challenge ALL students. In my opinion, teachers need to rethink what we do in class, as well as how we do it.  This will allow our students more time for practice and feedback, as well as the possibility of eliminating homework!    

Popular posts from this blog

Bottle Flipping

Last week someone posted article on Facebook about the newest trend with middle schoolers-bottle flipping.  If you haven't heard of it, you probably don't teach middle school or have a child in middle school! Consider  yourself lucky! If you know about it, then you also know it's annoying as heck.  Kids (usually boys), toss a partially filled water bottle into the air so that it flips in midair.  The goal is to have the bottle land upright.  This year I have had to ask several students to put their water bottles away because they wanted to flip them.  I know,  I'm mean!  



After reading the Facebook article I thought, "Hey!  I bet I can incorporate this into a lesson somehow."  Using my Oreo lesson as a model, that's just what I did.  First, I found two different articles about bottle flipping.  I went through both looking for key vocabulary words.  I then typed out the sentences with the words and created an activity where students had to guess the definit…

Oreos in China and Read 180

A few years ago I read an article about what happened when Kraft introduced the Oreo to the Chinese in 1996.  It was not a success.  The Chinese thought the filling was too sweet-the cookie too bitter.  Kraft almost pulled the beloved cookie off the shelves. Instead, they began a quest to find out how to make the Oreo appeal to the Chinese. Enter the green tea Oreo, the mango Oreo, and an Oreo in the shape of a straw (not sure that still qualifies as an Oreo).  The revamped Oreos were a huge success! I found the article fascinating and decided to design a lesson around  it to share with my students.

First I showed them a news clip from CNN about the topic. Then, I taught them a few vocabulary words that appear in the article using Kate Kinsella's method.  Next, we read the article together and marked the text. I did a think aloud as I read aloud to them.  After that, students created a T-Chart listing the ten most important words in the text, as well as five main ideas from the tex…

Making Comments on Student Writing Meaningful

As any English teacher knows, we spend countless hours grading and commenting on student work.  What I realized after a few years of teaching was that many students did not read my comments at all; they just looked at their grade. Some didn't even look at the rubric!   However, many students valued my feedback and relished every comment.  I felt as though I was wasting my time on more than half of the essays.   As evident from the next essay the students wrote, the majority of the students did not heed the advice I gave in the previous essay.  I came up with a solution!  Using Google Forms, I created a detailed survey for my students to fill out about the comments they received on their writing.  I will include pictures of various questions and answers.  Better yet, I told them that all responses would be read and a graded  for the thoughtfulness.  I had a sub that day, so I created a link to the form in my daily blog post for my class!  SO easy!  Students were forced to go back t…